top of page

8 September 2026

Back To The Market Research Blog: Graham Taylor

Graham Taylor updates us on the next phase of research for their Back To The Market Commission

Trying to find some structure through these various strands of research, some ideas connected, some disparate (and reflecting on the last blog post thing, trying to use less ellipses.).


BLACKSHIRTS IN DEVON – TODD GRAY


“Public laughter is the most deadly weapon known to England. And the Blackshirts are a scream.” – pp. 33 Blackshirts in Devon, Todd Gray


I am interested in humour as a thing, as a unifying thing, as something we can find community through, and as a way of redressing imbalances of power, or trying to bring powerful figures down. I guess the notion of the laughingstock, encapsulates that!


Throughout this research, I found numerous references to the prominence of singing as a disruptive act by counter protestors drowning out fascist talks, which jumped out at me. (from pp 33 – 50, various instances and references to Communists singing their anthems – emphasizing that dichotomy between the fascists and communists):


“There was only heckling and the communists tried a new tactic: they had community singing. They sang popular songs which attracted a greater number of the audience.” (pp 55)

“After the meeting, the Fascists left to a ‘chorus of juvenile booing’” (pp 58)

“Constant shouting, jeering and loud community singing made the speaker inaudible” (pp 63)

“They reported the meeting was rowdy with a large group of protestors interrupting Sir Oswald partly in singing ‘The Red Flag’.” (pp 65)

“The crowd had an extensive repertory of songs ‘Tell me the old, old story’, ‘Daisy Bell’, ‘They were only playing leap frog’ and other community ditties stood them in good stead. In the intervals they chorused ‘Hello, hello, hello’ or ‘Quack, quack, quack, quack, quack’ and fell upon other noise creating expedients” (pp 72)


The colours of shirts for different political affiliations and TRYBE self-identifications… One strand of work within my practice is in collaboration with the Creative Entity TRYBE, which generally results in modified clothing and accessories, playing around ideas of subcultural belonging and making ones way into ones wardrobe rather than buying ones way in. I thought it was really interesting how for a brief moment, political affiliations seem to have been embodied in items of clothing, in a tribal sartorial moment that feels like it parallels football shirts and how they relate to tribal belonging and being able to identify or know a simple, key thing about another person quite immediately from a clothing choice they have made.


Celebrity and Mosely and the formation of people around him – possibly could be the literalising of the language I am using/literalising metaphors, playing with camera flashes as a way of signalling the flashmob (Morse code flashes – or is that overcomplicating things?). The relationship to the unravelling of the 1933 rally in Plymouth where a journalist and photographer from the British Union of Fascists (B.U.F.) sympathetic paper the Western Morning News were attacked by Blackshirts, and Mosely did not condemn the actions,

doubling down on it, quoted as saying “You fellows think you are God Almighty, and the Press is not going to be God Almighty. What good have the newspapers done us?” (pp 67) And how in the photographers account it revolves a lot around using the camera flash and documenting the chaos that was ensuing – “I fired a flash-light to endeavour to get an impression of the turmoil… The camera by this time had been torn completely from my wrist, despite the strap adhering to the steel side, and I saw a Fascist deliberately rip the back off, declaring triumphantly that he had the plates.” (pp 66-67). – The nature of documentation and the contentiousness of documentation feels like a relevant angle to pursue, along with using the action of camera flashes (probably from smart phones) in some way in the flash mob.


Following on from media reporting of the events in Plymouth in 1933, at a Labour meeting on the 14th November, “the Chairman, Mr E. V. Watering of the Plymouth National Union of General and Municipal Workers, say ‘the best answer to Fascism is not to go into the Market Place and chase people, or repeat their tactics. The best answer is for all you who believe in democracy to join up in the democratic movements” (pp 73)


The spectacle element of Mosely talking in the Pannier Market also feels relevant to add, interested as I am in pursuing (or attempting to pursue, in one way or another) a non-spectacular mode of performance. “They not only heard a well-known charismatic national figure, which was a rarity in Barnstaple, but there was on offer a theatrical showmanship unlike anything in any other party.” (pp. 103)


ANTISEMITISM AND TOTALITARIANISM


In reading around this commission, I have started reading The Origins of Totalitarianism by Hannah Arendt. I fully intended to finish it when I began this commission but other things have come up and life gets in the way of research unfortunately. One thing I thought was particularly pertinent though, to this local context of historical fascism, was how central antisemitism is in Arendt’s view to totalitarianism. It is there in the opening line of her book: “Many still consider it an accident that Nazi ideology centred around antisemitism and that Nazi policy, consistently and uncompromisingly, aim at the persecution and finally the extermination of the Jews.” (Origins of Totalitarianism, pp. 3). This doesn’t feel surprising, knowing what we know now about the holocaust and the Nazi atrocities that happened during World War 2, and Arendt being a German-born Jewish philosopher – and I am not in any way attempting to contend this as a necessary part of totalitarianism. I thought it was interesting how in Todd Gray’s analysis of fascism not taking hold in Devon, which his book covers, he does note about how, as rhetoric at fascist rallies grew more extreme and started being more antisemitic it didn’t particularly land with the local people as they were less aware of Jewish people on the whole. Gray notes, in relation to a tumultuous evening of speeches where some speakers had been brought down from other parts of the country that “[Michael] Goulding’s use of anti-Semitism appears to have been different from the content of the speeches of local Fascists.” (pp. 73) This just felt like an interesting observation to share from the research; that if antisemitism is central to Nazism, and the antisemitic ideological elements of what the British Union of Fascists were offering were particularly unpopular or didn’t gain my traction in Devon, perhaps this is one of the contributing reasons or factors why fascism didn’t take hold in Devon.


PROTEST MUSIC


Below is a non-exhaustive list of some protest songs that I am interested in working with adapting, playing with the idea of karaoke as a way to bring people together into an informal performance atmosphere and situation to explore the legacy of using music to contend, disrupt and protest with. I am interested in playing with the lyrics and re-working some for updated and potentially more local concerns to play with that legacy, and hopefully be amusing too…


“No Trump, no KKK, no fascist USA!” When the self-proclaimed billionaire reality-TV star was elected president on a racist platform in 2016, that chant became a fixture of protests around the country; Green Day once even recited it at the American Music Awards. Dave Dictor, the frontman of Austin punks MDC, came up with those words (with “No war” instead of “No Trump”) in 1982 for the vicious hardcore rager “Born to Die,” which appeared on the band’s debut album, provocatively titled Millions of Dead Cops. At the time, he was blasting an uptick in neo-Nazis at Texas punk gigs, but he’s now proud of how the tune continues to resonate. “America is heading down a very dark road,” he said in 2016. “So, yeah, ‘No Trump, no KKK, no fascist USA!’” (https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-lists/best-protest-songs-1235154848/h-e-r-i-cant-breathe-1235231006/ - about MDC – Born to Die, entry 36)


Bob Marley and the Wailers – Get Up Stand Up

Joni Mitchell – Big Yellow Taxi

Imagine – John Lennon and Yoko Ono

Knockin’ on Heaven’s Door (my neighbours door)

Tubthumping – Chumbawumba

Know Your Rights – The Clash

The Revolution Will Not Be Televised – Gil Scott Heron


When it comes to great protest songs, subtlety is entirely unnecessary, as Motown stalwarts Norman Whitfield and Barrett Strong demonstrated with their gloriously blunt composition “War”: “What is it good for? Absolutely nothing!” The funkier original recording of “War,” by the Temptations, also has its moments, but it took Strong’s forceful, horn-blasting rearrangement — it may be the single hardest rocking Motown smash — and gifted second-stringer Starr’s emphatic delivery (“Huh!”) to really get it across. The song hit Number One at the height of the Vietnam War, with radios nationwide blasting lines like “Induction/Destruction/Who wants to die,” and returned to the Top 10 in 1986 when Bruce Springsteen released his revved-up live cover as a single. (https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-lists/best-protest-songs-1235154848/grandmaster-flash-and-the-furious-five-the-message-7-1235230212/ about War – Edwin Star, number 24)


THOUGHTS ABOUT PERFORMANCE, aiming for a more pedestrian performance…?


An ongoing strand of research within my practice going back quite a few years is these potentials for performance to occupy very everyday spaces in our lives, and the way that these could be performance art (if we allow the idea of performance art to be other than the most

transgressive edge of it, which feels similar to thinking about all painting exclusively as abstract expressionist painting – but this is a whole tirade/ramble/essay for another day!). I am interested in these informal moments of performing, and how they allow us to occupy a limelight for a moment. This is less a piece of research strictly, more of a slight mission statement/nod towards where the research is likely to head next.



Using money raised by National Lottery players, The National Lottery Heritage Fund supports projects that connect people and communities with the UK’s heritage. Thanks to National Lottery players, we will be able to deliver a year-long project that provides research opportunities, fun activities for the community, and the chance for people to think more deeply about what the Pannier Market means to our area.



Studio KIND at The Corn Store Barnstaple Pannier Market, EX31 1SY

lottery_Logo_White RGB.png
English_Made_Possible_logo_white_PNG.png
print.png

© 2023 Studio KIND

community interest company 12914790

bottom of page